here's a reason that the historical nickname of the "Hermit Kingdom"
for the old unified Korea is now applied to the closed North Korea -
officially known as the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK).
The country is
notoriously difficult to get information on and its sanctions-hit
economy is said to operate on a number of different levels, including a
black market, with the government not even releasing official trade
statistics.
CNN examines the North Korean economy and how Pyongyang generates its income.
What's the overall condition of North Korea's economy?
Not good. North Korea's
economy is one of the world's "most centrally directed and least open"
and faces "chronic economic problems," according to the CIA World Factbook -- which collects information for U.S. government agencies.
"Industrial capital stock
is nearly beyond repair as a result of years of underinvestment,
shortages of spare parts, and poor maintenance. Large-scale military
spending draws off resources needed for investment and civilian
consumption," it continues.
The factbook projected
data from a 1999 OECD study to estimate North Korea's Gross Domestic
Product (GDP) in 2011 to be $1,800 per capita.
It puts growth at 0.8%. However, U.N. estimates for 2011 put per capita GDP at $506 and growth at -0.1.
In comparison, the factbook estimates South Korea's GDP per capita in 2011 to be $31,700 and puts growth at 3.6%. Figures for 2012 were $32,400 and 2% respectively.
What are North Korea's main sources of income?
The factbook
defines North Korea's industries as military products, machine
building, electrical power, chemicals, mining, metallurgy, textiles,
food processing and tourism.
Its main exports were
minerals, metallurgical products, manufactures including armaments,
textiles and agricultural and fishery products and its main imports
petroleum, coking coal, machinery and equipment, textiles and grain, it
says.
Estimated industry accounted for nearly half of GDP, followed by services and agriculture, the factbook says.
South Korea's Ministry of Unification
put the amount of trade between the two countries in 2011 at about $1.7
billion. Of that, about $914 million was inbound and $800 million
outbound. Government and private humanitarian assistance to North Korea
totaled about $17.4 million, the ministry said.
Jang Jin-sung is the editor-in-chief of the website New Focus International,
which produces news based on a network of North Korean exiles and
sources within North Korea. Jang himself in 2004 fled North Korea, where
he said he had been on the DPRK Central Broadcasting Committee and the
country's Poet Laureate.
Jang said South Korean
investments generated the bulk of North Korea's foreign currency income
with another large chunk of income coming from trade with China. The
largest portion of this was from the arms trade, he said.
All North Korean
businesses involved with China were also required to give part of their
profits -- usually more than 50% -- to the government's financial
organization known as "Office 38" as "loyalty offerings," Jang said.
Who are North Korea's trading partners?
The CIA World Factbook
said China accounted for an estimated 67.2% of North Korea's exports
and 61.6% of imports in 2011. South Korea accounted for 19.4% of exports
and 20% of imports, while India received an estimated 3.6% of exports
and the European Union provided about 4% of imports in 2011.
Professor Jim Hoare is a senior teaching fellow at the University of London's School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS). He established Britain's first embassy in North Korea in 2001.
Hoare said that for a
time in the early part of the last decade South Korea had been
Pyongyang's main known trading partner. However, that had deteriorated
since the last president -- Lee Myung-bak -- ended Seoul's previous
policy of engagement and China became Pyongyang's main trading partner.
"There are Chinese goods
all over the country. China supplies it with oil and food stuffs and
everything from buses to toilet seats," Hoare said.
What interest does China have in helping North Korea?
It's commonly believed
that Beijing feels it is safer to have North Korea on its border than
U.S. ally South Korea, Jang said. However, China moved against North
Korea when it voted in favor of the U.N. resolution condemning Pyonyang's nuclear test earlier this year.
Jang said he believed
China was supporting sanctions in response to attempts by North Korea's
military to claw back power it had lost under the regency rule of Kim
Jong Un's uncle Jang Song-taek and his aunt Kim Kyong-hui. The military
under Kim Jong Il had created a headache for China and that it would
rather have the regency holding power, he said.
Writing for 38north.org,
Jenny Jun speculated that Beijing might have "experienced a classic
mismatch between means and ends when efforts to maintain the status quo
by propping up the internal regime ended up propping up the North's
nuclear program as well."
Read more: Will China finally 'bite' North Korea
What standard of living do ordinary North Koreans have?
In 2011, UNICEF estimated
that about a quarter of North Korea's population -- or six million
people -- did not have enough to eat. Nearly a million of those were
children under the age of five, it said. UNICEF said food was rationed
in North Korea and that the country was "susceptible to food crises
because of political and economic isolation, and climate change."
The World Food Programme says
North Korea continues "to face regular, significant food shortages,"
with one in every three children chronically malnourished or too short
for their age.
The United States
suspended shipments of food aid to North Korea in 2009 after the North
started rejecting shipments amid tensions over Pyongyang's nuclear
program and concerns that the supplies were not reaching those most in
need.
In March 2012, Pyongyang agreed to halt portions of its nuclear and missile programs and accept the return of nuclear inspectors in exchange for 240,000 metric tons of U.S. food aid.
However, later the same month North Korea's announcement of another rocket test ended the deal.
Hoare said the standard
of living in Pyongyang differed from other parts of the country.
"Pyongyang is the elite. A lot of people do have money -- the
restaurants are used by Koreans, officials and others. Elsewhere, senior
officials will have access to funds.
"Most people live a pretty hand-to-mouth existence in the North apart from the elite."
The diet of North
Koreans was a "much more reduced one than that in the South," he said.
"Most people live on grains and vegetables with meat and fish very,
very, rare in their diet. Even in Pyongyang, people aren't living that
high on the hog," he said, although the elite and foreigners were
protected.
Why is North Korea's economy in such bad shape?
The official economy was
based around heavy industry on North Korea's east coast and until at
least the mid-1970s, North Korea was one of the two main industrial
nations in Asia, alongside Japan, Hoare said. While not an official
member, North Korea had also benefited from the Soviet-led Council for
Mutual Economic Assistance -- an economic union between Soviet states
referred to as Comecon.
However, the collapse of
the Soviet Union and a series of natural disasters saw its industrial
sector enter a steep decline in the 1980s, which further intensified in
the 1990s, leaving the economy "pretty decrepit," he said. The country
also had an oil shortage. "It used to get its oil from the Soviet Union,
it doesn't anymore," Hoare said. Agriculture had been on a "downward
spiral" since the 1980s, with an overdependence on fertilizers. "The
land is worn out, people are worn out, equipment is worn out."
But it's difficult to
get reliable information on North Korea's economy. Hoare said Pyongyang
had not published any statistics on its economy since the early 1960s.
"This is all a very murky and difficult area. It's not clear, it is
opaque and it's hard to get very precise figures and an exact picture.
That's the nature of the animal," he said.
The country also had electricity shortages, he said, which was one of Pyongyang's arguments for developing nuclear power.
Since Pyongyang's first nuclear test in 2006, the U.N. Security Council has also targeted North Korea with sanctions over its nuclear and ballistic missile programs.
It has frozen economic
assets controlled by entities engaged in or providing support for North
Korea's nuclear and ballistic missile-related programs.
New sanctions introduced in March blocked the sale of luxury goods -- such as yachts and certain high-end jewelry -- to North Korea.
Don't the sanctions affect ordinary North Koreans?
U.S. Ambassador to the
United Nations Susan Rice said the block on luxury goods would mean
"North Korea's ruling elite, who have been living large while
impoverishing their people, will pay a direct price" for the country's
nuclear activities.
Jang said a body known
as "Office 38" generated money for North Korea's ruling party and the
infrastructure of the elite and had been seen as Kim Jong Il's personal
fund when he was alive. It was foreign currency based, he said.
He said there was also a "people's economy" mainly based on the black market since North Korea's won currency had lost value.
This market economy had
emerged "partly as a coping mechanism as a result of the famine - since
the 1990s," Hoare said. He broke the economies down into the official
economy, the people's economy, a military economy and an economy "to
keep the leadership in the style to which it is accustomed."
What about the arms trade?
In its March 2013 resolution following North Korea's February nuclear test,
the U.N. Security Council referred to the Korea Mining Development
Trading Corporation (KOMID), as North Korea's "primary arms dealer and
main exporter of goods and equipment related to ballistic missiles and
conventional weapons."
On April 2 2013, North Korea was one of three U.N. member states -- alongside Syria and Iran -- to vote against the organization's first treaty to regulate the global arms trade.
What other illicit trades is North Korea allegedly involved in?
North Korean citizens, including government officials have been involved in drug trafficking for years, according to the CIA World Factbook. It said in recent years North Korea had been linked to large shipments of heroin and methamphetamine.
Other illegal exports North Korea had intended for foreigners had come back to bite the country, Jang said. Counterfeit notes
proved to be too poor a quality for foreign use but had ended up on the
North Korean market. The problem was so widespread that Pyongyang would
not accept widely counterfeit $100 notes for loyalty offerings,
insisting $50 notes were paid instead, he said. For its part, the North
Koreans have denied any involvement in counterfeiting.
Similarly, recreational
drugs intended for international criminal markets had instead become a
domestic headache, with many North Koreans now suffering from addiction
to drugs such as meth and opium, he said. Click here to read New Focus' article on drugs in North Korea.
North Korea has denied involvement in illegal drugs and arms smuggling.
So how do ordinary North Koreans get by?
North Korea had
traditionally fed its people but when the Soviet Union collapsed they
had nothing and started bartering for food and all kinds of items, Jang
said. Items were brought in from China to be traded so Chinese traders
dominate the people's market.
New Focus International reported
that black-market trading "provides the main source of income for most
North Koreans." The black-markets were known as "jangmadang," it said.
Hoare said that when
North Korea's economy had been stronger, workers had received money
through the state's Public Distribution System. "Wages are worthless but
now people trade on the markets."
He said markets were
"tolerated" and could sometimes be seen down side streets. "My wife and I
once walked through what was known as a 'frogs market'." The term arose
because traders would "leap up and disappear like frogs and then
reassemble behind you as it were."
What currency is used in North Korea?
The DPRK's official
currency is the North Korean won, but Jang said everything in North
Korea was pegged on the U.S. dollar, including the black market economy.
The won was effectively "like toilet paper" he said and because all
business was done using dollars the currency was used by people to
barter even at the lowest levels of North Korean society.
Pyongyang had tried to
revalue the currency but because everyone used U.S. dollars to trade,
the dollar consistently went up and the won continued to fall in value,
he said.
Hoare said euros were
increasingly being used in some areas because North Koreans were worried
the U.S. would somehow cut off dollars. Foreign currency flowed into
North Korea in a number of ways including cross border trade with China
and visiting foreigners, he said. All embassies also had to operate in
foreign currency.
"We were not supposed to
handle North Korean money. So it's pretty widespread. If you go into a
hotel or restaurant prices are in foreign currency rather than Korean
won," he said. North Koreans in Japan or South Korea and defectors were
also reportedly sending money back -- usually through China, Hoare said.
In its article on jangmadang,
New Focus International describes how money sent by a defector to his
family in North Korea is laundered on the illegal markets.
What is the Kaesong Industrial Complex?
North Korea has said it will pull out all of its workers
and suspend operations at the Kaesong Industrial Complex, accusing the
South of seeking "to turn the zone into a hotbed of war."
The complex sits on the
North's side of the border but houses the operations of several of South
Korean companies. The complex is considered to be an important source
of hard currency for Kim Jong Un's regime. More than 50,000 North
Koreans work in the zone, producing hundreds of millions of dollars
worth of goods each year. Those workers earn on average $134 a month, of
which North Korean authorities take about 45% in various taxes.
South Korean company Hyandai Asan -- affiliated to the carmaker Hyundai -- was involved in the complex's development.
Hoare said the complex
was "all that's left of the engagement policy all that was used from
1997 on." Jang said it was the last card of any significance held by
North Korea as Pyongyang knew that outsiders saw it as a symbol of
cooperation.
Are there any other such joint projects between the Koreas?
The only other joint business project had been the Mount Kumgang Tourist Region, Hoare said, Hyundai Asan operated tours.
However, tours were
suspended when a North Korean guard shot dead a South Korean woman in
2008 and Pyongyang refused Seoul's request for an inquiry. "North Korea
effectively confiscated the South Korean complex and began to use it
themselves for tourism," Hoare said. "There was talk in 2007 of
developing other such complexes but then there was a change of
president."
0 comments:
Post a Comment